This page may contain affiliate links. So I receive a small commission at no cost to you when you make a purchase using my link. This post is about the delicious sandwich called Pastrami and Swiss on Rye!
Can you imagine at the age of 19 being mistaken for someone else? Then can you imagine finding out that that person is your twin? How about if a third individual came to light? And then amazingly you found out that you were a triplet, and not a twin? It sounds incredible, but this story is true!
This story is told in an amazing documentary called “Three Identical Strangers.” I won’t go into details because I don’t want to spoil the film for those who haven’t seen it. We watched this film on our recent Sunday movie night, and the setting of the film is New York.
During movie nights I love to cook a meal for that evening that has something to do with the film we are watching. For example either the setting of the movie, or food actually eaten or highlighted in the film can inspire the meal. The pastrami on rye sandwich is famous in New York. So “Three Identical Strangers” gave me the excuse to whip up one of these amazing sandwiches for our movie night dinner.
Originally Romanian Jews brought pastrami on rye to New York City. Now Jewish delis, such as Katz’s Delicatessen, serve hot pastrami sandwiches on rye. You must have one of these sandwiches while in New York! This recipe pays homage to this incredible sandwich with a few tweaks. It is perfectly delicious though!
My hope is that you’ll feel like you’re sitting in a Jewish deli in New York when you take your first bite out of this sandwich. Be sure to serve kosher dill pickles with this delicacy. Enjoy!
Some Other Sandwiches You May Enjoy!
Healthy Turkey Sandwich With Grilled Zucchini
I invite you to come along on this food and travel journey with me! So please sign up to get the latest recipes and inspiration for you to expand your food comfort zone! It’s an incredible journey, please join me by signing up here. 🙂
Cheers!
Grace
Pastrami and Swiss On Rye
Ingredients
- spreadable butter I used Challenge
- 3/4 lb pastrami
- spicy brown mustard
- 8 slices swiss cheese
- 8 slices rye bread
Instructions
- Preheat your oven to 300 F
- Lightly butter both sides of the 8 slices of rye bread
- Heat up your skillet to med high, and lightly toast each side of your rye bread. Keep a close eye so that it doesn’t burn. Toasting time will be approximately 30 sec – 1 minute or so.
- To keep the toasted bread from getting soggy, “tent” them by standing them up on their edges (see photo)
- Once the slices have cooled, add 1/4 of the pastrami to the bottom slice of your sandwich. Repeat for a total of 4 sandwiches
- Add 2 slices of swiss cheese on top of the pastrami, and then as much spicy brown mustard as you like. Repeat for a total of 4 sandwiches
- Top with the top slice of your sandwich. Repeat for a total of 4 sandwiches.
- Place your sandwiches in the 300 F oven for approximately 10 minutes or until the swiss cheese has started to melt
- Remove and serve with dill pickles
Great recipe! Really yummy. I also use Challenge butter, :). I really want to thank you for the movie recommendation. I’m about the same age as the triplets and lived in Sullivan County in 1982 – 1986 ( Monticello) and most of my friends were Sullivan County Community College students. Yet, I’ve never heard this story! It’s riveting and brings back memories of the Catskills. I too was stopped by a NYS tooper on route 17, lol.
Hi Ellen! Thanks so much for your comments and I’m over the moon happy that you like the sandwich! Great choice of butter. 🙂 Also overjoyed that you enjoyed the movie and my goodness you have a close connection because of Sullivan County! It’s an incredible story I still can’t believe it! A very Happy New Year to you and your family and thank you again!!